US isn’t like Japan 10 years ago.
People say the US isn’t like Japan 10 years ago. I agree. Actually
it’s WORSE! We have long believed that when the US bubble finally burst, there would be key lessons
that could be learnt from Japan’s experience a decade ago…with the US now entering its second
recession since the stock-market bubble burst and with a pronounced credit crunch unfolding (just like
Japan had), clients are more willing to listen to our gloomy story…
Many seek comfort that the Fed is well aware of the mistakes Japan made a decade ago and they have at
the helm an expert on the Great Depression. But that does not mean they can muffle the huge sucking
sound as debt excesses unwind…
Where the US is in a much worse state than Japan a decade ago is in its consumer finances. When Japan
went into its Ice Age in 1990, the household savings ratio stood at a lofty 15%. Hence as income declined,
consumers were able to run down savings to maintain living standards. In contrast, the US consumer is a spent force. So as US employment now slumps (flexible economy and all that), the US saving ratio is more likely to rise, causing a far deeper slump in GDP than we saw in Japan a decade ago…
But we also note that actually in Japan, despite real estate slumping from 1991 onwards, banks were not perceived to be a problem…until the second recession in their own Ice Age began to unfold just like the
US now… http://www.sgresearch.socgen.com





